Best Screw Extractor Top Reviews and Complete Detailed Guide 2018

By Tom Pelly | Reviews

Mar 01
best screw extractor

Removing broken or damaged bolts, studs, and fasteners doesn’t have to be that needlessly arduous and tricky. With my best screw extractor in tow, this often dreaded activity can be turned into a fun, highly efficient activity. And when I threw a full extractor kit in the mix, voila, this endeavor is now stress-free – a time well-spent regardless of the job at hand.

But getting the best screw extractor doesn’t come in handy if one isn’t equipped with the know-how to choosing only the right one for your needs. I spent a great 44 hours on reviewing and researching the best screw extractors on the market now and my findings are the ones I’m sharing in this post.

Today, you’ll not only get acquainted with my top five screw extractors but will ultimately be exposed as well to a buyer’s guide you only need to ever have.

The Five Best Screw Extractors

**Below, you will find more detailed reviews, but you can also click the links above to see current prices and read customer reviews on Amazon.

  • Material: 100% Carbon Steel
  • plus-circle
    Weight: 1.6 ounces 

Forget about being slowed down or impeded by a broken bolt or a stripped screw with Ontel SpeedOut Damaged Screw Extractor and Bolt Extractor.

The makers behind this product attest that it can take out damaged rivets in less than 10 seconds. They should also work on most screw types which include Philips and the hex. The 100 percent carbon steel made screw extractor can also work with any drill size.

Whether you’re a handyman, a contractor, or a carpenter, SpeedOut can also extract those deck or broken screw right out of a wood or metal. The proprietary system that comes with the product is enhanced by a durable, hardened steel, that is also reusable.

What We Lik​ed

  • Easy to use
  • thumbs-o-up
    Durable hardened steel
  • thumbs-o-up
    Works on wood and machine screws
  • thumbs-o-up
    Can remove stripped screw in less time
  • thumbs-o-up
    Ideal for carpenters, handymen, contractors
  • thumbs-o-up
    Works with any screw or any size of bolt

What We Didn't Like

  • Drill points could have been better
  • thumbs-o-down
    Overall material is not premium-made
  • thumbs-o-down
    Tend to dull a little quickly

  • Material: Hardened Steel
  • plus-circle
    Weight: 3.2 ounces

Productivity is literally and figuratively quadrupled with Fengbao’s 4PCS Damaged Screw Remover and Extractor. The accompanying package comes with four, able tools which also vary in terms of “remove diameter.”

The high-strength, durable steel is all crafted to withstand multiple extractions while rendering performance that is nothing short of excellent. The easy-to-use entry from Fengbao also comes with a case that is equally durable and compact as the extractors. Needless to say, you won’t be having issues storing these little ones.

No jobs will ever be left undone with Fengbao’s Remover and Extractor set. So whether you’re dealing with rusted screws, free-spinning screws, deck screws, or occasional heads sans a screw grip, this handy tool should fit quite well to your arsenal.

What We Lik​ed

  • Robust steel
  • thumbs-o-up
    Comes with four varying bits
  • thumbs-o-up
    Comes with a handy, durable case
  • thumbs-o-up
    Easy to store
  • thumbs-o-up
    Highly flexible

What We Didn't Like

  • Instructions could have been a little more improved
  • thumbs-o-down
    Dulls easily

  • Material: Cobalt
  • plus-circle
    Weight: 13.6 ounces 

The Irwin Hanson Spiral Extractor and Drill Bit Set boasts of easy outspiral flutes that goes extra deeper into any surface as these bits get drilled. The distinctive, aggressive design is known to heighten the grip resistance, which in turn doubles the product’s fastener-removing prowess.

In addition, the cobalt-made entry from Irwin Tools is equipped with a generous ten varying bit sizes – a flexible feature that should leave no stone unturned. The set is enveloped in a case that is also as precious and robust as its bits inside.

Meanwhile, finding the right and best tool that you need among the choice is made easy as the accompanying sizes are etched right onto each of these extractors and drill bits. Talk about going extra! Our third contender should be your go-to screw extractor if you’re planning to remove broken studs, bolts, fittings, and socket screws.

What We Lik​ed

  • Grabs and removes even small-sized screws
  • thumbs-o-up
    Super sharp drills
  • thumbs-o-up
    Ideal for broken studs, bolts, and fittings
  • thumbs-o-up
    Comes with etched markings for size and recommended drill bit
  • thumbs-o-up
    Equipped with a distinctive aggressive left hand spiral design for more gripping power
  • thumbs-o-up
    Generous 10-piece set

What We Didn't Like

  • Drill bits and extractors are a bit on the fragile side
  • thumbs-o-down
    Drill bits are dulled easily
  • thumbs-o-down
    Extractors are prone to slipping

  • Material: Durable Hardened Steel
  • plus-circle
    Weight: 3.2 ounces 

Got a lot of screw heads and rusted screws or bolts to fix on? Aisxle Damaged Screw Extractor and Remove Set is especially made to cater to those whose projects are often entangled with these impediments.

From its robust and durable hardened steel and extra hard coating, your job is made more efficiently, plus a screw extractor that should last for years. The stripped screw extractor kit is equipped with four varying size bits that should come in handy for any screw types and size.

One of its Aisxle entry’s hallmark features is its simple-to-use offerings. Users are only required to drill a hole right in a designated surface before unscrewing it with the extractor for an effortless removal.

After just a number of seconds, removing the stubbornest of screws has never been that easy. Our fourth entry also comes with a handy and durable case for storage.

What We Lik​ed

  • Easy to use
  • thumbs-o-up
    Very well-made; excellent built
  • thumbs-o-up
    Ideal for tough removals
  • thumbs-o-up
    Extractor set works with any drill and any screw size or bolt
  • thumbs-o-up
    Comes with Iron-Clad 3 Tier 100% Money Back Guarantee

What We Didn't Like

  • Dulls easily
  • thumbs-o-down
    Threads on the extractor are not coarse enough

  • Material: Premium Steel
  • plus-circle
    Weight: 2.56 ounces 

Now is the time to bid adieu to your troublesome, rusty screws as the Damaged Screw Extractor and Remove Set from Dr. Meter has pulled out all its stops to guarantee you a painless removal of sorts!

Remove these pesky screws in a nanosecond using its premium bits that are crafted from top-of-the-line stainless steel that has a hardness of 63-65 HRC. Meanwhile, the product’s galvanized outer layer should keep the inevitable rustiness away, making these removers all the more long-lasting.

The included bits are also exceedingly user-friendly. They are known to be highly adaptable, allowing users to insert them right into any drill with ease and confidence. Our last entry is very much ideal for those handymen who have just gotten started and those who are always on the go, thanks to its portable and convenient packaging.

What We Lik​ed

  • Bits are made from high-quality stainless steel
  • thumbs-o-up
    Highly adaptable bits
  • thumbs-o-up
    Extracts screws easily
  • thumbs-o-up
    Comes with flexible options for bits
  • thumbs-o-up
    Comes with a carrying box

What We Didn't Like

  • None

A Quick Buyer’s Guide to Choosing the Best Screw Extractor

For a screw extractor to be qualified as the best one of the bunch, one must be aware of the top qualities and considerations when it comes to selecting the right one. Below are the ones I’ve collated to help you choose the best one for your needs:

1. Types of Screw Extractors

Before anything else, you must be familiarized with two of the most common types of screw extractor: the straight-fluted and the spiral-fluted. Also deemed as the “easy out” between the two, screws that are spiral-fluted are normally developed for left-handed users who use them on right-handed threads.

The use of spiral-fluted screws has a known drawback, and that is their propensity to tightening the screw as opposed to have it loosened, driven by the accompanying wedging action.

On the other hand, straight-fluted screws come without wedging and is equipped with lesser chance of having the screw tightened. Its known disadvantage is that for users to operate it, one must be accompanied by a tool or drill that is about the same size as the screw.

2. Screw Type

For the uninitiated, you’ll also be exposed to various types of screws as you go on with your tasks. Most of these types come in the form of the hex, Philipps, and other sorts. As it goes, it’s paramount that you determine the type of screw that you have before purchasing your screw extractor.

Make certain that these two, the screw type and the screw extractor, go hand-in-hand. This step should not only narrow down your selection but should ultimately get your job done in a much faster way.

3. Durability

How would you know if your screw extractor is up to any task you’re doing? An indication that your screw extractor is robust is that it shouldn’t bend or accumulate some scratches even when you’re extracting screws that are either stuck or highly damaged.

Durability in a screw extractor also entail that whenever you drop it accidentally, it shouldn’t incur some dents and you won’t have to deal with some fixing of some sort.

4. Efficiency

Perhaps the most vital feature a screw extractor must have is efficiency. No matter how durable and grand a type your screw extractor is, these still won’t fare well if it isn’t all that efficient. But just how do you know if a screw extractor is that effective? For starters, it must extract virtually anything, even the most banged up of screws.

Another sign of an effective screw extractor is its ability to extract the screws with ease and quickness. Should you experience this when trying out a new one on the market, then you must be holding the best one at that.

More importantly, a screw extractor shouldn’t get any form of damage and in turn, shouldn’t disfigure the surface or equipment you’re working on.

More Winning Tips: How to Use a Screw Extractor Safely and Effectively

Fixing a stripped or broken screws with a screw extractor is rendered futile if one doesn’t know how to use one. More importantly, if one isn’t too careful or practiced in using a screw extractor, it’s highly likely that your project might go south. Below are effective and safest ways to use a screw extractor:

1. The use of safety gear

As you’re most likely drilling into a metal or wood, you have to make sure that a safety gear is worn at all times. Goggles that are crafted with polycarbonate lenses are deemed to be the best gear today.

2. The importance of a center punch

Next, ensure that the center punch is aligned right over the screw. The metal cylinder which is akin to a pen, a center punch can be found in a hardware store.

3. Hammering the punch

With a hammer, begin tapping the upper section of the punch. Make certain that you’re only striking it lightly. A small pivot is bound to appear if you do this correctly.

4. The thread cutting oil

The screw should be applied with a droplet of thread cutting oil. This should lubricate the metal, allowing you to drill it with less time.

5. The penetrating oil

For rusty screws, apply a drop of penetrating oil. This type of oil should also work for those that are attached to metal surfaces. It should loosen these screws accordingly, thereby allowing you to remove them easily. If you don’t have this oil type, you can opt for an acetone instead.

The Verdict

The Standout: Aisle Damaged Screw Extractor and Remove Set

Aisle isn’t backing down to providing the utmost quality to its products. And with its Damaged Screw Extractor and Remove Set, the highest quality and strong performance from its extractors are only to be experienced that much.

This four-piece screw extractor set is definitely your go-to choice when you’re looking for an effective product that is also both durable and easy-to-use.

Did you like this post? Do you think Aisle got it right? If you have anything to add, share, or as, please feel free to sound them off in the comment section below and I’ll get back to you soon!

About the Author

Hi, I'm Tom Pelly. I'm a home designer and founder of TidyTheHome. While doing my job, I found that choosing a right tool to repair home is an essential factor. As a result, my blog is designed to provide you with important information of latest tools to help you complete job faster and more professional. Explore my blog to get all information you need in home improvement.

Leave a Comment:

Leave a Comment: